Reading the Bible as a Single Narrative: A New Kind of Book Club

by Will Spokes August 24, 2014

Dr. Bart Ehrman teaches New Testament Introduction to undergraduates at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. A few years ago he started asking his undergraduate classes about their views of the Bible. He recounts, “The first day of class, with over three hundred students present, I ask: ‘How many of you would agree with the proposition that the Bible is the inspired Word of God?’ Whoosh! Virtually everyone in the auditorium raises their hand. I then ask, ‘How many of you have read one or more of the Harry Potter books?’ Whoosh! The whole auditorium. Then I ask, ‘And how many of you have read the entire Bible?’ Scattered hands, a few students here and there.

“I always laugh and say, ‘Okay, look. I’m not saying that I think God wrote the Bible. You’re telling me that you think God wrote the Bible. I can see why you might want to read a book by J. K. Rowling. But if God wrote a book…wouldn’t you want to see what he has to say?’ For me it’s just one of the mysteries of the universe: how so many people can revere the Bible and think that in it is God’s inspired revelation to his people, and yet know so little about it.”

According to a joint study by the Barna Group and the American Bible Society, 88% of American households own on average about four Bibles. However, only 37% of Americans read the Bible once a week or more. One of the main reasons given for this trend is busyness. 40% of Americans—up from 33% last year—report being too busy with life’s responsibilities to read the Bible. Another reason is the rise of skepticism especially among millenials, those born between the early 1980’s and 2000’s. “The number of those who are skeptical or agnostic toward the Bible—who believe that the Bible is ‘just another book of teachings written by men that contains stories and advice’—has nearly doubled from 10% to 19% in just three years. This is now equal to the number of people who are Bible engaged—who read the Bible at least four times a week and believe it is the actual or inspired Word of God.”

People often struggle to read the Bible and make sense of it because they read it in bits and pieces. Instead of reading it as one story, we often read it like a collection of fables and aphorisms with little awareness of the historical context or the overall flow of the story. Sadly, many Bible study resources perpetuate this way of reading the Bible by breaking up the text into discrete sections for analysis.

But what if we tried reading the Bible as one unfolding narrative? What if we read the Bible like a story that actually happened with a plot line, characters, action, and drama? What if we read the Bible and discussed it like we would at a book club?

This past summer for an adult Bible school class, that’s exactly what one group of folks did. They read through the entire New Testament. However, instead of using the familiarly formatted texts, they read from a reformatted New Testament with no headings, chapter or verse numbers. The books of the New Testament in this text are rearranged along roughly chronological lines. The format of the time together was like a book club. Discussion focused on the previous week’s reading using the following questions to foster discussion:

1. What was new or compelling to you?
2. What questions did you have?
3. Was there anything that bothered you?
4. What did you learn about loving God?
5. What did you learn about loving others?

The purpose of this experiment was simply to read the scriptures in community with others; to let the scriptures speak and see what we discover about ourselves and the God of the Bible. Every week people came to the Bible Book Club meetings with fresh insights on the texts of the week and a renewed understanding of God’s love for them. It was a great experience as a Tenth adult Bible school class, but now we want to extend this experience beyond the walls of Tenth. 

On Sunday, August 31, 2014 we will host a lunch for all those interested in learning more about the Bible Book Club format and how you can facilitate these groups in your neighborhoods, workplaces or current small groups. If you are interested in attending or if you would like more information on the upcoming fall run of Bible Book Club, please email Ellie at for details. 


© 2024 Tenth Presbyterian Church.

Permissions: You are permitted and encouraged to reproduce and distribute this material in its entirety or in unaltered excerpts, as long as you do not charge a fee. For Internet posting, please use only unaltered excerpts (not the content in its entirety) and provide a hyperlink to this page, or embed the entire material hosted on Tenth channels. You may not re-upload the material in its entirety. Any exceptions to the above must be approved by Tenth Presbyterian Church.

Please include the following statement on any distributed copy: By Will Spokes. © 2024 Tenth Presbyterian Church. Website: